How to Evaluate a Multifamily Property in Central Florida

January 9, 2026 | Buyers | Sellers

A practical guide to knowing whether a deal is truly worth it

Thinking about buying a multifamily property in Central Florida, but unsure whether it’s actually a good deal?

On paper, almost every property looks promising. The listing photos look great. The rent numbers seem solid. The area “appears” up and coming.

But the real question is simple:

Will this property actually make you money — and fit your goals — after you buy it?

The answer comes from looking beyond the listing and evaluating four things:

The building
The location
The income and expenses
The plan for the property

This guide walks you through how small and mid-size investors (typically up to 100 units) evaluate multifamily deals in Central Florida so you can feel confident before making an offer.

If you’re actively looking at multifamily properties in Central Florida, understanding how to evaluate a deal before you buy is critical.

1. Start with the building itself

Begin by answering a basic question: What exactly are you buying?

Look at:

Number of units and unit mix (studios, 1-bed, 2-bed, etc.)
Typical square footage and layout
Property age and major systems (roof, plumbing, electric, HVAC)

More units can mean more income, but only if:

The units are in good condition
The layouts make sense
They attract the renters who actually live in that area

Next, take an honest look at the physical condition of the property.

Watch for:

Water damage or roof problems
Signs of mold
Old electrical panels or wiring
Aging plumbing
Poor insulation or drafty windows
Parking issues or poor lighting

In Central Florida specifically, also pay attention to:

Hurricane protection and roof age
Insurance requirements
Flood zones
Drainage concerns during heavy rains

Make a list of:

Repairs you must address right away
Updates you’d like to do over time

Those items affect both cash needed up front and future returns — and can make a “cheap” property very expensive.

These repair and upgrade costs play a major role in multifamily due diligence and should always be factored into your purchase analysis.

2. Evaluate the neighborhood — not just the address

With multifamily real estate, you’re not just buying a building. You’re buying into the jobs, people, and economy around it.

In Central Florida, renters are often influenced by:

Proximity to major employers (hospital systems, schools, theme parks, logistics centers)
Access to highways (I-4, 417, 408, Turnpike)
Lifestyle areas (Winter Park, Lake Nona, Davenport, Clermont, Downtown Orlando)
Commute times

Look at:

Overall feel of the neighborhood
Condition of nearby properties
New construction or redevelopment nearby
Vacancy levels in the area

Other meaningful indicators include:

Crime trends over time
School ratings (if the area attracts families)
Access to groceries, transit, healthcare, and restaurants

Then look ahead.

Central Florida continues to experience strong population growth and job creation.

Ask:

Are new employers moving in?
Are new roads or transit options planned?
Is nearby retail expanding or closing?

Growth generally supports higher demand. Higher demand helps protect:

Rent levels
Long-term appreciation
Resale value

As Multifamily Investment Broker Joe LaFleur says, you’re not just investing in a building; you’re investing in the people and jobs around it.

Understanding job growth, population trends, and new development is essential when evaluating the Central Florida multifamily market.

3. Understand how the property makes money

Before you buy, get clear on one thing:

How much income is this property really producing today, not just in theory?

Review:

Current rents for each unit
What tenants are actually paying
Vacancy history
History of late payments or evictions

Then compare current rents to realistic market rents for similar properties nearby.

There is an important difference between:

“This could rent for more someday.”
and
“Similar units nearby are currently renting for more.”

Comparing current rents to market rents is a key step in multifamily investment analysis, especially for properties between 10 and 150 units.

Also think about simple value-add opportunities, such as:

Modest interior updates
Adding or improving laundry facilities
Storage or parking fees where appropriate
Small curb-appeal improvements

These improvements are common in value-add multifamily investing, where small changes can significantly improve cash flow over time.

Finally, review operating costs such as:

Insurance (a major factor in Florida)
Property taxes, which often increase after the sale
Maintenance and repairs
Property management
Landscaping, pest control, and utilities

The goal is to understand what is left after bills are paid. That number ultimately determines whether a property supports your investment goals.

Learn more:
Evaluating the risks and rewards of investing in multifamily real estate

4. Make sure the deal fits your goals — not someone else’s

Every investor is different.

Some investors want a steady monthly income. Others are more focused on improving a property and increasing value over time.

Ask yourself:

Do I want income now, appreciation later, or both?
How much renovation work am I comfortable taking on?
Do I want to manage tenants or hire a property management company?
How long do I plan to hold the property?

A property that is perfect for one investor may be completely wrong for another.

For example:

A fully renovated property may provide lower upside but immediate income.
An older property in a growing area may require more work but offer more potential.

There is no single correct approach — there is only the right match for your strategy and comfort level.

5. Don’t be afraid to get help evaluating deals

Even experienced investors seek a second opinion.

Multifamily brokers and property managers can help you:

Identify red flags you may overlook
Confirm whether rents and expenses are realistic
Understand Florida-specific insurance and tax impacts
Estimate renovation costs
Separate true upside from unrealistic expectations

Many newer investors hesitate because they worry about repairs, tenant issues, turnovers, or evictions. Good third-party property management can take much of that stress off your shoulders.

Experienced investors choose professional multifamily property management to reduce day-to-day involvement while protecting long-term value.

You don’t have to evaluate every deal on your own.

6. Build confidence in your next multifamily purchase

When you carefully review the building, the neighborhood, the income and expenses, and your investment goals, you move from guessing to making informed decisions.

That is how you reduce surprises, protect your capital, and build long-term wealth through multifamily real estate in Central Florida.

Let our Central Florida multifamily experts help. At 100Units, we specialize in small and mid-size multifamily properties across Central Florida. Our team helps investors:

Analyze deals
Understand true property value
Identify risks early
Uncover real opportunities aligned with your goals

Whether you are purchasing your first 10-unit property or expanding toward 100+ units, we are here to help.

Back to all blogs

Previous Blog